Lawyers in Canada: Davis LLP - Legal Advisors Since 1892

Canadian government announces nineteen successful projects in response to a call for proposals under the Renewable and Clean Energy portion of the Clean Energy Fund

The Honourable Lisa Raitt, Canada's Minister of Natural Resources, today announced support for nineteen (19) projects selected in response to a call for proposals under the Renewable and Clean Energy portion of the Clean Energy Fund. Up to $146 million will be invested over five (5) years to support the demonstration of renewable and clean energy across the country, including integrated community energy solutions, smart grid technology, and renewable applications with solar, wind, tidal and geothermal energy.

Under the Clean Energy Fund, part of the Government of Canada's Economic Action Plan (Budget 2009), the government is to invest almost $1 billion over five (5) years in research, development and demonstration projects to advance Canadian leadership in clean energy technologies. This includes large-scale carbon capture and storage demonstration projects, three (3) of which have already been announced totaling $466 million from the fund, as well as smaller-scale demonstration projects of renewable and alternative energy technologies such as those announced today. Total investments under the Clean Energy Fund for large and small demonstration projects are to benefit Canada's economy by leveraging nearly $3.5 billion in further investments by industry and other levels of government.

The Government is now inviting the project proponents to begin negotiations toward formal contribution agreements to set the conditions under which funding will be delivered. The funding amounts are expected to range from $2.5 million to $20 million for each project. However, until a written contribution agreement is signed by both parties, no commitment or obligation exists on the part of the Government of Canada to make a financial contribution to these projects.

Successful Project Descriptions

A) Projects expected to receive $2.5-$5 million

1. Biomass-based Urban Central Heating Demonstration
Lead proponent: SSQ, Société immobilière Inc.
Strategic Area: Buildings/Community Energy Systems
Location: Québec, Québec
Purpose: La Cité Verte is an innovative real estate project, which combines various initiatives related to sustainable development such as renewable energy utilization, energy efficient design, the management of water consumption, energy and waste management. The funding will support the installation of a biomass and wood-based district heating system. This project combines a variety of technologies and partners.

2. Utility-scale Electricity Storage Demonstration using New and Re-purposed Lithium Ion Automotive Batteries
Lead proponent: CEATI International Inc.
Strategic Area: Electricity Storage
Location: Toronto and Cornwall, Ontario, and Manitoba
Purpose: This project will address electricity storage for renewable and high-density urban applications. The project will demonstrate utility-scale electricity storage systems using new and re-purposed automotive batteries. This concept will reduce cost for electric vehicle batteries providing a future market to meet urban electricity demand using automotive batteries.

3. Energy Management Business Intelligence Platform Development and Demonstration
Lead proponent: Power Measurement Ltd.
Strategic Area: Smart Grid
Location: Commercial buildings in Calgary, Alberta, Ontario and BCIT in Burnaby, British Columbia
Purpose: This project will develop and demonstrate smart grid technology, voluntary load curtailment and peak shaving in a commercial building setting. Most projects of this type to date have focused on residences. This technology will also enable tenants to voluntarily reduce their demand based on real-time price signals.

4. Wind and Storage Demonstration in a First Nations Community
Lead proponent: Cowessess First Nation
Strategic Area: Wind/Storage
Location: Cowessess, Saskatchewan
Purpose: This project aims to demonstrate a combined wind and storage energy system in a First Nation community. The successful demonstration would prove this system as a model for other First Nation's communities across Canada.

5. Bioenergy Optimization Program Demonstration
Lead proponent: Manitoba Hydro
Strategic Area: Bioenergy
Location: Five locations in Manitoba
Purpose: This project is comprised of five different bioenergy systems at five different project sites. The project demonstrates collaboration between utility companies and customers. It is anticipated that the project will help to remove the perceived barrier of technical and operational risk and will promote the wide-scale adoption of bioenergy systems in Canada.

6. Offshore Wave Energy Demonstration
Lead proponent: SyncWave Systems Inc.
Strategic Area: Marine/Hydro
Location: Offshore Central Vancouver Island near Tofino, British Columbia
Purpose: This project will demonstrate the performance, operations and life cycle of a pre-commercial 100-kW wave energy device in ocean conditions typical of British Columbia's open coast. Canada has potentially significant wave energy resources, and it is important for Canada to participate in demonstrations to further the technology, understanding of ocean conditions and the regulatory environment.

7. Demonstration of Waste-heat Recovery at Compressor Stations
Lead proponent: Great Northern Power Corp.
Strategic Area: Hybrid Systems/Northern
Location: Compressor Stations in Alberta and British Columbia
Purpose: This project plans to demonstrate waste-heat recovery systems on a variety of stationary, reciprocating engines greater than 1,000 hp. A successful demonstration has the opportunity to lead to commercialization and wide-scale adoption of this technology at compressor stations and other industrial applications across Canada.

8. Residential Implementation of Solar-thermal Heating Systems
Lead proponent: Enbridge Gas Distribution Inc.
Strategic Area: Buildings/Solar
Location: Greater Toronto Area, Ontario
Purpose: The project will use different types of solar collectors and storage technologies to verify and compare their costs, performance and technical qualities. The project has the ability to validate the technology and provide integrated systems at a lower cost to consumers, thereby allowing greater market penetration.

9. Food and Yard Waste Anaerobic Digestion to Electricity Demonstration
Lead proponent: Harvest Power Canada Ltd.
Strategic Area: Bioenergy
Location: Fraser Richmond Soil and Fibre, British Columbia
Purpose: This project would be Canada's first high-efficiency system for producing up to 1 MW of renewable energy from food and yard waste. If successful, this technology has the potential to be rapidly deployed across Canada as a mechanism to divert food wastes from landfills and produce renewable energy.

B) Projects expected to receive $5-$10 million

10. Demonstration of Heat and Power from Biomass Gasification
Lead proponent: Nexterra Systems Corp.
Strategic Area: Bioenergy
Location: UBC Point Grey Campus, Vancouver, British Columbia
Purpose: This project will showcase biomass gasification integrated with an internal combustion engine generator in a novel, small-scale combined heat and power demonstration suited for on-site applications at public institutions, industrial facilities, and northern and remote Canadian communities. The project has the potential to overcome the difficulty of gas clean up and opens up the possibility of significant replication in Canada and overseas.

11. Energy Storage and Demand Response for Near-capacity Substation
Lead proponent: BC Hydro
Strategic Area: Smart Grid/Electricity Storage
Location: Golden and Field, British Columbia
Purpose: This project demonstrates the integration of energy storage as a mechanism for reducing electricity demand at near-peak capacity substations. This type of solution has the ability to be used in other remote communities where the grid reliability is low and the cost of the transmission line upgrade is uneconomical.

12. Interactive Smart Zone Demonstration in Québec
Lead proponent: Hydro-Québec - Institut de recherche
Strategic Area: Smart Grid
Location: Boucherville, Québec
Purpose: This project will ensure the installation of an interactive network area in a neighbourhood of Boucherville. This will demonstrate different technologies and concepts related to modernization of electrical networks, in particular the deployment of infrastructure for charging electric and hybrid rechargeable vehicles.

13. Biomass and Coal Co-firing Demonstration in Coal Plants
Lead proponent: Nova Scotia Power
Strategic Area: Bioenergy
Location: Coal Plants in Nova Scotia
Purpose: This demonstration project aims to determine optimum fuel blends for the potential co-firing of wood-based biomass with coal as a mechanism to partially replace fossil fuels with sustainable energy sources in coal plants. If successful, there is potential for wide-scale implementation across Canada and the United States.

C) Projects expected to receive $10-$20 million

14. Tidal Energy Project in the Bay of Fundy
Lead proponent: Fundy Ocean Research Centre for Energy (FORCE)
Strategic Area: Marine/Hydro
Location: Minas Passage, Bay of Fundy, Nova Scotia
Purpose: The project plans to validate the performance and resilience of tidal current turbines in the Minas Passage of the Bay of Fundy. This will be the first Canadian deployment of commercial-scale tidal turbines. The project has the potential to advance tidal energy in Canada, provide economic impacts in the Atlantic region and place Canada as a world leader in marine renewable energy.

15. Northern Application of a Geothermal District Heating System
Lead proponent: City of Yellowknife
Strategic Area: Northern/Community Energy System
Location: Yellowknife, Northwest Territories
Purpose: The City of Yellowknife is in advanced stages of project engineering and plans to install a district heating system by extracting heat from the abandoned Con Mine. This project has the potential to provide a cost effective and a more environmentally friendly alternative to fossil fuel based heat. The information that will come out of this project on the effect of extracting ground-source heat from an existing aquifer and its associated long-term heat capacity will help determine if this technology could be replicated in other northern communities.

16. Electricity Load Control Demonstration
Lead proponent: New Brunswick Power Corporation
Strategic Area: Smart Grid
Location: Four maritime communities in New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island
Purpose: Traditionally, to accommodate the intermittent nature of wind power, other generation sources are required to follow the net effect of variation in load and wind power production. This project focuses on the integration between smart grid technologies, customer loads and intermittent renewables in a region with potentially significant renewable electricity capacity. It will allow utilities to better understand how customers will react to smart grid and which loads can be controlled by real-time demand balancing in up to 750 buildings, thereby assisting these utilities to capitalize on renewable resources in the region.

17. A 9-MW Wind Technology Research and Development Park
Lead proponent: Wind Energy Institute of Canada
Strategic Area: Wind/Storage
Location: Prince Edward Island
Purpose: The 9-MW wind park proposed will be the first wind/storage combination in Prince Edward Island. The project's research base has a strong focus on information dissemination and would be a good base for supporting additional wind research.

18. Demonstration of Fish-friendly and VLH Turbines in Existing Low-head Water-control Dams
Lead proponent: Eco Joule Inc.
Strategic Area: Marine/Hydro
Location: Mississippi River System, Ontario
Purpose: This project will demonstrate three in-stream hydro technologies including fish-friendly, low-head hydro turbines along an existing water-controlled river system in Ontario. It has the opportunity to prove the technology concept, demonstrate cooperation with a conservation organization, and reduce the barriers to commercialization.

19. Community-based Geothermal Demonstration in a Remote First Nations Community
Lead proponent: Borealis GeoPower Inc./Acho Dene Koe First Nation
Strategic Area: Hybrid Systems/Northern
Location: Fort Liard, Northwest Territories
Purpose: This project will demonstrate how a northern community can use a geothermal resource to generate electricity and heat, thereby reducing the entire community's fossil fuel demand and energy costs. A successful demonstration will provide a model for other northern and First Nations communities with available geothermal resources.

World's first concept tires made of renewable biomass arrive in Copenhagen in time for United Nations Climate Change Conference

The world's first concept demonstration tires made with BioIsoprene technology, a breakthrough alternative which aims to replace a petrochemically produced ingredient in the manufacture of synthetic rubber with renewable biomass, made their debut in Copenhagen, Denmark, this week. One tire will make appearances at several special events during the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen (COP 15), while the other tire will be on display at a lounge in the common departure area at the Copenhagen International Airport throughout December 21.

The tires made with BioIsoprene are the result of a collaboration between Genencor, a world leader in industrial biotechnology and a pioneer in enzyme innovation and division of Danisco A/S, and Goodyear, one of the world's largest and well known tire companies.

Beyond tires, BioIsoprene offers a huge potential in all kinds of other applications where petroleum-based rubber products and adhesives. The market for isoprene could reach up to 11 billion pounds per year by 2012. Genencor plans to bring the technology to pilot stage within two years, followed by commercial production.

Philippe Lavielle, Executive VP of Business Development for Genencor declared: "We're building advanced biorefineries of the future through strategic collaborations, such as our work with Goodyear and our joint venture DuPont Danisco Cellulosic Ethanol, as well as public-private partnerships. By joining forces with other industry leaders and leveraging our cutting edge biotech capabilities, we're able to accelerate development and deployment of breakthrough technologies like BioIsoprene."

The development by Goodyear of its first concept tire manufactured using a bio-based alternative to the petroleum-derived raw material isoprene is a good example of how traditional industry has taken notice of the consumer's pursuit for more environmentally friendly products and of the growing importance of corporate social responsibility, a part of which results from lessening one's impact on the environment.

India announces energy efficiency "cap-and-trade" initiative

India's Prime Minister, Dr. Manmohan Singh, announced an ambitious new energy efficiency initiative for his country. The "National Mission on Enhanced Energy Efficiency" is intended to cut energy consumption by 5% and greenhouse gas emissions by 100 megatonnes by 2015.

The Mission comprises several complementary initiatives:

• a cap-and-trade system for energy efficiency allowances;
• expanded use of the global carbon markets, particularly the Kyoto Clean Development Mechanism, to fund energy efficiency projects;
• the creation of two new funds, one to provide guarantees to banks for loans to energy-efficiency projects and the other to support investment in the manufacturing of energy-efficient products and provision of energy-efficiency services; and
• the promotion of Energy Service Company ("ESCO") based upgrades to energy systems in buildings, municipalities and agricultural operations.

Of these initiatives, the proposed cap-and-trade system has attracted the most media attention (see Environmental Finance and Reuters). The Prime Minister's announcement describes it as a "Perform, Achieve and Trade" scheme whereby the government will assign energy efficiency improvement targets to businesses in energy-intensive sectors (the cap). Businesses that beat their targets will generate Energy Savings Certificates that can be sold to businesses that miss their targets (the trade).

The Prime Minister anticipates that the Mission will result in $15 billion of energy efficiency transactions, although it is unclear if these comprise only trades of Energy Savings Certificates or also other economic activity under the Mission.

The proposed system is squarely aimed at energy efficiency and does not provide for any direct regulation of greenhouse gas emissions. Nevertheless, it is suspected that the announcement was purposefully made in the run-up to the Copenhagen negotiations. India has steadfastly refused to agree to binding emissions reduction targets under the successor to Kyoto. The proposed energy efficiency scheme, which has the potential to reduce the country's emissions, will likely be held up at Copenhagen as evidence that India is willing to address climate change - but on its own terms.

And the Clean Energy Dialogue Begins

Our Environment Minister took a trip to Washington to meet with U.S. legislators and to promote the Clean Energy Dialogue this week.

On Monday Minister Prentice met with Senator John Kerry, who is the head of the Senate foreign relations committee. On Tuesday, the Minister met with Energy Secretary Steven Chu, Todd Stern, the special envoy on climate change and Lisa Jackson, the new head of the Environmental Protection Agency.

The Minister's discussions this week in Washington focused on the "expansion of clean energy research and the deployment of clean energy technology".

The Canadian press seemed to expect that the discussions would focus on Alberta's oilsands and not research and technology and the Clean Energy Dialogue. However, the Minister confirmed that the oilsands came up only "tangentially" in his discussions with the American legislators, including with Henry Waxman, the new chairman of the house energy and commerce committee and an ardent environmentalist.

Canada is the largest supplier of energy to the United States. Emissions from the oilsands, which are the subject of some "high minded hypocrisy" this month, are 50-70 times less than the aggregate of the emissions from coal plants in the United States.

America's challenge is clean coal; Canada's may be clean oil. But given that the oilsands were not, by the Minister's account, the focus of his discussions with legislators in Washington, perhaps both Canada and the U.S. recognize that neither country is going to gain any ground by pointing fingers. The right approach is to meet these challenges by looking forward and finding solutions in research and the development of new clean technologies. Isn't that what the Clean Energy Dialogue is for?

Ottawa's GHG offset system to include a "fast track" project approval system for first 6 months

submitted by Grant Boyle

On August 9 the federal government published a draft Guide for Protocol Developers for Canada’s Offset System for Greenhouse Gases. The draft Guide will undergo a 60 day consultation period before a final Guide is published. The Guide is intended to provide details on the requirements to complete an Offset System Quantification Protocol and the steps that must be followed to create offset credits under the federal GHG emissions framework.

Projects must take place in Canada, must have started on or after January 1, 2000, must be surplus to all legal requirements (federal, provincial/territorial and regional) and go beyond what is expected from the receipt of other climate change incentives (federal, provincial/territorial). Credits may be issued for reductions achieved after January 1, 2008.

The quantification requirements in the Guide are based on the ISO 14064 standard. The Guide does not provide or recommend an approach to quantify GHG reductions from specific project types and will rely on project proponents to develop and submit their own protocols to Environment Canada for approval, unless the protocol type has already been approved by the Ministry. The approvals process is expected to take 5-8 months.

During the first six months of the operation of the Offset System, Environment Canada will implement a modified and accelerated process to review and approve Offset System Quantification Protocols that are derived from a list of 40 “external protocols” from other systems, including: the Clean Development Mechanism, Alberta’s Specified Gas Emitters Regulation, the California Climate Action Registry, the Greenhouse Gas Abatement Scheme in New South Wales, France’s Offset System, and the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative. The Guide includes a proposed list of external protocols for “fast track” approval:

Agriculture
*Including Edible Oils in Cattle Feeding Regimes (Alberta)
*Reducing Days on Feed of Cattle (Alberta)
*Reducing the Slaughter Age of Cattle (Alberta)
*Anaerobic Decomposition of Agricultural Materials (Alberta)
*Livestock Project Reporting Protocol Capturing And Combusting Methane From *Manure Management Systems (California)
*GHG Emission Reductions From Manure Management Systems (CDM)
*Innovative Feeding Of Swine and Storing and Spreading of Swine Manure (Alberta)
*Tillage System Management (Alberta)

Energy Efficiency
*Waste Gas Or Waste Heat Or Waste Pressure Based Energy Systems (CDM)
*Residential Buildings (Alberta)
*Commercial Buildings(Alberta)
*Waste Heat Recovery Projects (Alberta)
*Waste Heat Recovery Project - Streamlined(Alberta)
*Energy Efficiency Projects (Alberta)

Forestry
*Afforestation Projects (Alberta)
*Forest Management (California)

Fossil Fuels
*Industrial Fuel Switching From Coal Or Petroleum Fuels To Natural Gas (CDM)
*Switching From Coal And/Or Petroleum Fuels To Natural Gas In Existing Power Plants For Electricity Generation (CDM)

Geological Sequestration
*Acid Gas Injection (Alberta)
*Enhanced Oil Recovery (Alberta)

Methane
*Landfill Gas Capture And Combustion (Alberta)
*Landfill Project Reporting Protocol Collecting And Combusting Methane From Landfills (California)
*Landfill Gas Project Activities (CDM)
*Coal Bed Methane, Coal Mine Methane And Ventilation Air Methane Capture And Use For Power (Electrical Or Motive) And Heat And/Or Destruction By Flaring Or Catalytic Oxidation (CDM)
*Aerobic Composting (Alberta)
*Aerobic Landfill Bioreactor Projects (Alberta)
*Coalmine Methane and Abandoned Mine Methane Capture and Destruction Projects (General Electric AES)
*Waste Water Treatment Methane Capture and Destruction Projects (General Electric AES)

Renewable Energy
*Biomass to Energy from Biomass Combustion Facilities (Alberta)
*Electricity Generation From Biomass Residues (CDM)
*Run Of River Power Generation (Alberta)
*Solar Power Generation (Alberta)
*Wind Power Generation (Alberta)
*Introduction Of A New Primary District Heating System (CDM)
*Grid Connected Electricity Generation From Renewable Sources (CDM)

Transportation
*For Gravel And Lightly Surfaced Road Re-Surfacing Projects (Alberta)
*For Freight Modal Shifting (Alberta)

Waste
*Recovery & Utilization Of Gas From Oil Wells That Would Otherwise Be Flared (CDM)
*Non-Incineration Thermal Waste Management (Alberta)

Other
*Biofuels Productions And Usage (Alberta)
*Catalytic Reductions Ofn2o Inside The Ammonia Burner Of Nitric Acid Plants (CDM)

Canada back on track with its Kyoto registry

Canada appears to be on track to launch a Kyoto-compliant registry for tracking transactions of greenhosue gas emission reduction credits. Recall from a previous posting that the UNFCCC's Compliance Committee had concluded in April that Canada had not established a registry system as required by the Kyoto Protocol.

Canada subsequently provided additional information about the progress of the registry to the UNFCCC's Enforcement Branch. An independent assessment report deemed the registry to be "sufficiently compliant with the registry requirements." As a result the Enforcement Branch decided to halt its investigation and no longer plans to impose sanctions for non-compliance.

With Canada's registry again on track, regulated entities in Canada may eventually be able to purchase Certified Emissions Reductions ("CERs") from Clean Development Mechanism ("CDM") projects. The federal government's emissions reduction plan contemplates allowing companies to satisfy up to 10% of their reduction obilgations by purchasing CERs.

Carbon markets boom

Posted by Andrew Lord

The voluntary market for carbon credits more than tripled in 2007 to USD $331 million, while the much larger regulated market more than doubled to USD $64 billion. Those are the conclusions of two significant carbon reports released last week.

Ecosystem Marketplace and New Carbon Finance released State of the Voluntary Carbon Markets 2008 last week. The report notes that the volume of credits traded increased from 25 million tonnes CO2 equivalent (tCO2e) in 2006 to 65 million tCO2e in 2007. The average price of a tonne of CO2 jumped by $2 to $6.10. However the price remained very volatile in 2007, ranging from $1.62 per tCO2e to about $300 per tCO2e. That volatility is a reflection of the perceived problems with the quality of some credits, a perception that the market tried to address by introducing a number of voluntary credit standards during the year.

Also released last week was the World Bank's State and Trends of the Carbon Market 2008. This report focuses on the regulated carbon market, particularly the allowance market under the EU Emissions Trading Scheme and the project market under the Kyoto flexibility mechansms (Clean Development Mechanism and Joint Implementation). The value EU ETS trades, which comprised 78% of the overall regulated market, more than doubled to $50.4 billion, with the average price creeping up from just over $22 per tCO2e in 2006 to around $24.30 in 2007. In the project market, the big story in 2007 was the emergence of a strong secondary market for CERs. The value of trades in the secondary market increased by a factor of over 10 to $7.4 billion. The secondary market was largely occupied by aggregators who purchased a portfolio of CERs and sold guaranteed CERs backed by the portfolio and, in some case, credit-enhanced through the aggregators' banks. At about 28%, growth in the value of trades in the primary CDM market was strong, but not as vibrant as that in the secondary market.

New Carbon Marketplace Established by UN

Submitted by Andrew Lord.

The UNFCCC and URC just launched CDM Bazaar, a free information exchange service that aims to make the Clean Development Mechanism market more efficient. The portal connects CDM market participants (but does not provide an electronic marketplace for actual CER transactions). The site is divided into three major sections.

(1) Sellers area: profiles sellers, describes their current and planned CDM projects, and lists CERs available for purchase;

(2) Buyers area: profiles potential buyers; indicates how many CERs they want to purchase, and lists from what countries, project types and methodologies they would consider buying; and

(3) Service Providers area: offers a directory of carbon market technology and service providers.

Anybody can browse the site, but companies must register (at no cost) to be listed in one of the above areas. At the time of posting, the CDM Bazaar had 35 registered users, the majority of them in the Service Providers area. Hopefully this number will grow quickly.

The CDM Bazaar, which focuses on market participants, complements the existing CDM/JI Pipeline site, which focuses on projects. The CDM Pipeline not only lists projects that have been sent for validation/determination, but also provides links to approved methodologies, Designated Operational Entities, Accredited Independent Entities, and other project-related information.